This is mostly a summary of stuff that came up elsewhere, in order to move the discussion to a location where the owner does not get overburdened with comments. I have time for comments right now and I’m OK with organizing things
BTW if you prefer, I can try to set up OpenID on my blog so you can just log in with your LJ accounts.
I tried to sort stuff into headings…
Recommendations and finding them
Rose Lemberg had the idea that we should set up a recommendation depository and/or a book exchange as part of the Hugo project, and I wholeheartedly agree, because I keep on worrying about missing out on something. I know I find stuff which makes me go “how did I ever manage to miss this?! For years?!” all the time.
There is also the question of actually obtaining content. AFAIK, last year’s Worldcon membership came with ebooks of the shortlist, but that doesn’t solve the problem of what to nominate. So we will need to take a look at which publishers offer advance reviewer copies (or can be talked into some special deal) and in which formats. I can maintain the list, or we can set up some sort of CMS – a group blog, a wiki, anything you think would be a good idea.
Reviews, cooperation with other venues
I think we should also try to write reviews not only on our blogs, but hopefully in already established venues as well. I’ve already had a Hungarian online magazine show interest in response to my previous blog post, but we should also look for English-language venues – magazines, group blogs, etc., the more the merrier! I have experience writing book reviews in a variety of formats (from “one paragraph per book” to lengthy essays), but it’s quite hard to find markets for this sort of content, at least it’s been that way for me. Duotrope only shows fiction and poetry, and many magazines only have in-house reviews.
In addition to the extra publicity offered by other venues, there is also the financial aspect – I’m OK with doing some work as a volunteer, especially when something is close to my heart, but from time to time I like to receive compensation
I think this is also true for pretty much everyone else, especially members of underrepresented groups!
I’m not trying to say that everyone should rush to buy our reviews, I’m totally OK with sending queries and then getting rejected etc., so basically just going through the regular process of publication – but what I could really use is a list of places actively looking for reviews. I know Expanded Horizons is constantly on the lookout for reviews of spec fic related to underrepresented groups (payment is a flat fee of $30), but surely there are more magazines, we just need to find them. They need not be specifically diversity-oriented as long as they take reviews of spec fic.
What rubs me the wrong way is markets that pay less for reviews than fiction which then protest they do not get enough reviews, or that the reviewer pool is not sufficiently diverse. I can only speak for myself, but I have a limited amount of time and energy to spend on free time writing (as opposed to writing that pays my bills
), I’m not very rich either – especially compared to the average American -, and thus I tend to optimize for money. If a market pays the most for poetry, I’ll send them poetry. If they pay the most for fiction, I’ll send them fiction. Etc.
What people can do to help right now
I decided to split this off into a separate blog post…