Short story reviews: Clarkesworld, August 2011
Clarkesworld, Issue 59, August 2011
A really interesting issue which even includes a translated story…
Conservation of Shadows by Yoon Ha Lee (a Korean-American woman)
After Gord Sellar’s musical tale in the previous issue, we have another stylistic experiment in the pipeline, but this one actually works, and works very well. Yoon Ha Lee’s previous story in Clarkesworld sort of grew on me after a while, but this one I loved from the outset.
The plot is inspired by Sumerian mythology – the main character is identified as Inanna right at the outset, so this is hard to miss. Inanna’s descent to the underworld becomes a video game, with an inventory of items and a second-person narrative. I always think of text adventures when I see second-person viewpoints in prose (and I suspect many of my generation do), but very few works of non-interactive fiction exploit this association. I’m very pleased to see this one does.
Conservation of Shadows is a clear candidate for my Hugo nomination… I’ll try to put up my Battle of the Stories page soon IY”H (it still needs a button graphic), and then you’ll see the rankings so far.
The Fish of Lijiang by Chen Qiufan (a Chinese man), translated from the Chinese by Ken Liu
A translation! An actual translation! Rejoice! (Note the lack of an irony marker. We could certainly use more translations of world SF into English.)
This is a pushy, aggressive story. With Pantone colors. (Not kidding this time either.) It has the driving force of cyberpunk, with a brash, angry male protagonist. The plot uses experiential time to address issues of capitalism, the labor market, etc. It’s a very interesting read, though I wasn’t completely satisfied with the pacing, or how the main character needed everything to be spelled out for him. There was also a throwaway “I’m not a telepath” line that I resented. (I thought that was an American thing, having to reassure each other that they were not telepaths… pfff.)
One of the characters describes “robots playing Naxi folk music” as “a donkey braying with its balls cut off” and says that humans were much better. So here is some Naxi folk music, played by humans… All the online videos seem to be from the same tourist show. I picked a segment with an instrumental solo on a Jew’s harp-like instrument. (Incidentally, I can play the Jew’s harp, even though it has nothing to do with Jews.)





